Shadow Strategic Rail Authority
keywords: click to search
Phrases in [single square brackets] are hyperlinks in the original document
Phrases in [[double square brackets]] are editorial additions or corrections
Phrases in [[[triple square brackets]]] indicate embedded images or graphics in the original document. (These are not usually archived unless they contain significant additional information.)
I want to follow up my letter of the 10th August, the presentation to the
Association of Train Operating Companies on 13th September and Sir
Alastair's speech to the Institution of Highways and Transportation at Chester
on 17th September by formally inviting existing and would be franchise
holders to offer proposals for franchise replacement for all the existing
franchises which expire within the next 5 years.
I want to set out in this letter the kind of proposals I envisage receiving and from whom;
what I will be looking for in proposals;
some process issues.
As Sir Alastair mentioned in his speech in Chester, I anticipate proposals
might be received from
the current incumbent in relation to his existing franchise;
the current incumbent in relation to a modified geographical version of
his existing franchise;
current incumbents in relation to any other existing franchise;
would be franchise holders in relation to existing franchises,
but I wish to make it clear that in the absence of default I cannot terminate an
existing franchise. Those parties that wish to make a proposal in relation to an
existing franchise will have to reach agreement with the incumbent and myself
as to the terms for giving up or transferring that franchise.
Interest from would be franchise holders has already been stimulated by Sir
Alastair's speeches and resulting press content.
In selecting proposals to go forward I shall be looking for
the commitment to performance, customer services, innovation,
investment and efficiency;
the extent to which extra or earlier investment can be obtained;
the extent to which better performance can be secured;
the extent to which integrated transport measures both within the rail
network and between rail and other transport modes can be achieved,
including integrated public transport information systems;
affordability and value for money.
I shall also be looking for evidence of the proposals having been widely
consulted on with local authorities, the CRUCC, RUCCs network and, if
appropriate, LRPC and the Scottish and Welsh devolved bodies.
As I have said before I expect to start with only a small number of proposals
as a first tranche - no more than four franchises. The proposals to be selected
will be at my absolute discretion. Again I repeat what I said in my letter of the
10th August - there can be no guarantee of a successful renegotiation and I
always have the option of allowing franchises to expire and offering them for
Those parties who submit proposals will be expected to sign a Replacement
Process Agreement which, inter alia, will require them to
disclose to me financial and other information about their proposal on
an 'open book' basis;
(for existing incumbents) give their consent to the disclosure of historic,
financial and performance information relating to the existing franchise
to third parties;
prepare such disaggregated financial and performance information as I
may deem reasonably necessary for the purpose of evaluating variant
offers proposed by me;
supply a business plan supporting the initial proposal.
I expect to announce which franchise proposals will be taken forward in the
first tranche by the beginning of November. Other parties will then have sixty
days to bring forward alternative proposals for those franchises.
M J GRANT
Railhub Archive ::: 1999-10-12 SRA-001