National Audit Office
The sale of Eurostar
keywords: click to search
National Audit Office
Phrases in [single square brackets] are hyperlinks in the original document
Phrases in [[double square brackets]] are editorial additions or corrections
Phrases in [[[triple square brackets]]] indicate embedded images or graphics in the original document. (These are not usually archived unless they contain significant additional information.)
The sale of Eurostar
type Press release
note PN: 59/15
The sale of the UK government’s entire financial interest in Eurostar (40% stake and preference share) generated proceeds of £757.1 million, resulted in the government achieving its objective of maximising proceeds, and represented value for money for the taxpayer, according to a report by the National Audit Office.
However, the total taxpayer investment in Eurostar, prior to its incorporation, is significantly greater than the proceeds generated from this sale. Taxpayer spending on the HS1 project, of which Eurostar cross-channel train service is one part, was over £8 billion. The NAO estimates that UK taxpayers’ financial investment directly related to the Eurostar train service amounts to approximately £3 billion.
The NAO believes that the timing of the sale, agreed in 2014, was primarily driven by the desire to sell prior to the 2015 election. Eurostar’s profits are forecast to increase from 2016 once it has introduced new higher-capacity trains, the first of which should be rolled out at the end of 2015. The government considered waiting to sell after the new trains were introduced as it thought higher profits could feed through into a higher price. It concluded, however, that any delay would come with uncertainty and risks, so the government decided to sell in early 2015 rather than wait.
The sale of the 40% stake was run well by the government and its advisers. Changes to the shareholder agreement made the investment attractive to a wide range of investors, such as pension funds. There was competitive tension between the bidders. The information provided to potential bidders on the company’s past performance and future prospects, combined with the meetings with management and SNCF (the majority shareholder) had the desired effect, enabling bidders to gain confidence in the prospects of the business and encouraging higher bids. The three final-round bids were around a third higher than these bidders’ first round bids.
The sale price of £585.1 million for the 40% stake was almost double (92% higher than) the government’s central valuation of £305 million. To a large extent, the gap demonstrates the successful sale, which attracted competitive bids and took place during benign market conditions. Without questioning the integrity of the three valuations, however, the NAO considers that credible valuations above £500 million could have been supported without changing the assumptions about the business plan or emergence of competition, but rather by altering two key inputs.
Eurostar paid £172 million to redeem the UK government’s preference share following negotiation with the company and its other shareholders. The preference share was created when the company was incorporated in 2010. Eurostar carried forward some £1.8 billion of historical trading losses at this time, to offset against future taxable profits and thereby reduce UK corporation tax (as standard tax rules allow). The preference share was due to pay a dividend to the government based on its utilisation of these tax losses – the first dividend was due to be paid in 2015. Eurostar has been profitable since incorporation and is forecast to continue to be so. The preference share was predicted by the government’s financial adviser to pay an estimated £243 million in cash to the government over the next decade. If paid these dividends would pay off, when discounted, an estimated £216 million of government debt (including interest accrued). However the potential future stream of preference share dividends was uncertain, in contrast to the upfront cash payment of £172 million made to redeem the preference share.
Sale costs amounted to £8.2 million, just over 1% of the proceeds of the 40% stake in Eurostar and the preference share. The majority of this was paid to the financial adviser, UBS, and the legal adviser, Freshfields. The legal cost for an internal transfer of shares, from the Department for Transport to HM Treasury, was £0.5 million. HM Treasury was concerned about the cost of the legal work and considered re-procuring the legal adviser during the sale process but it decided a change of legal team mid-way through the process would be inefficient and problematic. The government also agreed to pay Eurostar management and key employees up to £0.3 million in total on successful completion of the sale.
“The government prepared well for the sale of Eurostar and the sale process was run effectively. I regard the sale as value for money. This case illustrates some general lessons for government as it embarks on an unprecedented asset sales programme forecast to exceed £62bn over this Parliament. These lessons include: the need for detailed business cases in support of the decision to sell; objective and robust valuations to decide if, and when, to sell; and getting good value from advisers.”
Amyas Morse, head of the National Audit Office, 6 November 2015
Notes for Editors
Sale price for 40% stake in Eurostar
Price paid by Eurostar to redeem the preference share
Expressions of interest for Eurostar shares
Bids in the final round of bidding
Duration of the formal sale process, October 2014 to March 2015
The sale price (£585.1 million) was 192% of the government’s valuation of £305 million.
Transaction fees as a proportion of total proceeds (the 40% stake and preference share).
Estimate for total taxpayer investment in the Eurostar train service, one part of the High Speed 1 project, which cost taxpayers more than £8 billion.
1. The government agreed to sell its 40% stake in Eurostar International Limited (Eurostar) for £585.1 million in March 2015. The winning bidder was Patina Rail LLP, a consortium made up of Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec (CDPQ), a Canadian investment fund, and Hermes Infrastructure (Hermes), a UK-based fund. The government also allowed Eurostar, in a separate transaction, to redeem the preference share for £172 million.
2. Eurostar was incorporated as company in 2010 – previously it had been an unincorporated joint venture. The other shareholders are the national rail operators of France (SNCF) who own a 55% stake and Belgium (SNCB) who own a 5% stake.
3. Eurostar should not be confused with Eurotunnel, the company that owns the Channel Tunnel infrastructure and operates vehicle shuttle services between the UK and France.
4. Press notices and reports are available from the date of publication on the NAO website, which is at the NAO's website. Hard copies can be obtained by using the relevant links on the NAO website.
5. The National Audit Office scrutinises public spending for Parliament and is independent of government. The Comptroller and Auditor General (C&AG), Sir Amyas Morse KCB, is an Officer of the House of Commons and leads the NAO, which employs some 810 people. The C&AG certifies the accounts of all government departments and many other public sector bodies. He has statutory authority to examine and report to Parliament on whether departments and the bodies they fund have used their resources efficiently, effectively, and with economy. Our studies evaluate the value for money of public spending, nationally and locally. Our recommendations and reports on good practice help government improve public services, and our work led to audited savings of £1.15 billion in 2014.
Direct line: 020 7798 7861 Mobile: 07985 260074 Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Railhub Archive ::: 2015-11-06 NAO-001